Campaign reviews look more alike than people think. Reviews from international agencies, from local boutiques, from media owners who also do consulting. Reviews for budgets of 50,000 dirhams and reviews for budgets of several million euros.
And in all these reviews — whether beautiful or ugly, long or short, well presented or sloppy — the same absences are always found. The same information that is never there. The same questions nobody answers.
It is not an oversight. It is a selection. Conscious or unconscious — but a selection.
"A campaign review is a communication document before being an analysis document. And like any communication document — it highlights what flatters and plays down what disturbs."
What is always found in a review
Before talking about what is absent — let us look at what is always present. Because it is not trivial.
Reach is always there. The number of people reached. Often impressive. Rarely put in context — that is, compared to what was planned or to what was needed to reach the objective.
Impressions are always there. Millions. Sometimes tens of millions. Without ever explaining how many of these impressions were real — seen by a real human being in a context where they could perceive them.
Comparisons with benchmarks are always there. "Our engagement rate is above the sector average." The benchmark is carefully chosen to showcase the campaign — never to challenge it.
And a positive conclusion is always there. Even when the results are mediocre — the review ends with optimistic recommendations for the next campaign.
What is never found
The big absentees from reviews
Why these absences are not oversights
Not all agencies are dishonest. But the system in which they operate creates incentives that run against full transparency.
An agency that clearly shows that 30% of the budget was misallocated risks losing the next budget. An agency that presents brilliant results — even incomplete ones — is more likely to continue the relationship. In this context — the selection of the information presented is rational.
That is why the solution is not to change agencies — it is to change what you ask for.
What you should systematically ask for
The next time your agency presents a review — ask these questions before approving anything.
What was the initial objective — precisely — and what percentage was achieved? Not "did we run a good campaign" — but "what did we say we would produce, and did we produce it?"
What is the real cost per business result? Not per impression, not per click — per sale, per lead, per new customer. If your agency cannot answer this question — it is an important signal.
Which media or formats worked least well — and why? If your agency tells you everything worked perfectly — be wary. In every campaign, something works less well. Honesty on this point is a sign of professional maturity.
What would be done differently next time? The answer to this question will tell you everything about the real quality of the partnership.
"The best agency is not the one that presents the most beautiful reviews. It is the one that tells you the truth — even when it is uncomfortable."
One last thing
These absences in reviews are not solely the agencies' responsibility. They are also the responsibility of advertisers who never asked to see this information.
If you have never asked for the real cost per business result — your agency has no reason to calculate it for you. If you have never asked what underperformed — your agency has no reason to show you.
The review you receive is a reflection of the questions you ask. Ask better questions — and you will get better reviews.