Back to Insights
Practice · Analysis
What to look for first in a campaign review
A quick reading method makes it possible to identify the essentials of a campaign review in a few minutes. Here is how to proceed.
Flare Point Media·May 2026·7 min read
Take a 47-slide review. Harmonious colors, charts everywhere, beautiful presentation. The right reflex: 45 seconds on the first 40 slides — and 6 minutes on the last 7.
Because that is where the real information was hiding. Discreet. Buried in the volume. But there.
A review is not read in order. There is a way of tackling it that shows what matters in a few minutes. And often, what matters most is precisely what is not shown to you first.
How to read a review — in this precise order
1
Look for the initial objectives — on the first page
Every review should start by recalling the objectives that were set before the campaign. If this page does not exist — it is already a signal. It means the review is going to present results without telling you whether they match what was asked for.
The question to ask: What did we say we wanted to produce?
2
Look for the planned / delivered delta
For each metric presented — you have to find what had been planned. If the plan called for 500 GRP and the review presents 380 GRP as a success — that is a 24% gap that deserves an explanation. Many reviews present absolute results without comparing them to forecasts.
The question to ask: Did we deliver what we promised?
3
Read the conclusion before the rest
The conclusion of a review reveals the framing the agency wants to give the campaign. Is it honest about the limits? Does it identify points for improvement? Or is it 100% positive — which is almost always suspect in a real campaign?
The question to ask: Does the agency say anything difficult?
4
Look for the benchmarks used
When an agency compares its results to benchmarks — you must always look at which benchmarks. The sector? The platform? The period? A generic benchmark can hide mediocre performance. And a cleverly chosen benchmark can make good results look exceptional.
The question to ask: Are these benchmarks the right ones for this context?
5
Look for what is missing
Absent information is often more revealing than present information. No cost per business result? No comparison with forecasts? No analysis of the media that underperformed? These absences are signals. They indicate what the agency prefers not to show.
The question to ask: What is not in this review?
6
Look for the effect on sales or awareness
The real test of a campaign — did it change something in the target's behavior or perception? This information is often missing from reviews. When it is present — even partially — that is where the most reading time should be invested.
The question to ask: What changed in the real world?
7
Look for the recommendations for what comes next
The recommendations reveal the quality of the agency's analysis. Are they generic — "increase the digital budget", "test new formats"? Or are they specific and anchored in the learnings of this particular campaign? The best recommendations show that the agency really learned something.
The question to ask: What did we learn that we did not know before?
"A quality review teaches something. A mediocre review confirms what was already known — bigger and in color."
The warning signs to spot immediately
Red flags in a review
No comparison with the initial objectives — or the initial objectives are not mentioned.
All results are positive — without exception. In any real campaign, something works less well.
The benchmarks are not sourced or are chosen in an obviously favorable way.
Delivery metrics dominate — with no attempt to link these metrics to business results.
The recommendations are generic and could have been written before the campaign.
The review runs to 40 slides but the useful information would fit in 5.
What this method reveals
By reading reviews with this grid, you find that the quality of a review is an excellent indicator of the quality of an agency. An agency that presents an honest review, with its successes and its limits, with specific learnings and concrete recommendations — is an agency that really works for its clients.
An agency that presents 40 slides of impressive metrics without ever mentioning a problem or a learning — is an agency that works for its own image.
This distinction is often worth more than any selection criterion.
Flare Point Media — an insider's view of media planning. Read more articles →