A few years ago, the question was "LinkedIn or Facebook?" Then "Instagram or Snapchat?" Now it is "TikTok or YouTube?" The question changes. The logic behind it — not really.
We choose a platform the way we choose a restaurant — because "everybody goes there." Not because it suits what we actually want to eat.
The real question nobody asks
Before even choosing between TikTok and YouTube — there is a more fundamental question to ask. What state of mind is the target in when it uses this platform? And is that state of mind compatible with what the brand wants to say to it?
On YouTube — someone is looking for something. They have an intent. They type a query or click a recommendation in an area that interests them. They are attentive, active, oriented toward specific content.
On TikTok — someone is scrolling. With no defined intent. The algorithm suggests, and they decide in two seconds whether it is worth stopping. They are in a reactive mode, guided by surprise, humor, movement.
It is not the same person. Even if it is the same person.
What the field shows
Brands that land on TikTok with their usual TV budget and classic advertising codes — and wonder why it does not work. The platform is not at fault. It is the message that is not suited to the target's mental state.
And conversely, brands that abandon YouTube because "young people no longer use it" — when their main target is 35 and actively looking for content in their category. They abandon the only place where their message would find a truly receptive audience.
Fashion should never dictate a media decision. Ever.
"The question is not which platform is popular. It is on which platform your target is in the state of mind that matches your message."
And what if the right answer is neither?
Sometimes — and this is an uncomfortable truth — neither TikTok nor YouTube is the right choice. Maybe your target is on LinkedIn. Or listens to the radio in the car. Or still watches TV in the evening.
Next time this question comes up in a meeting — resist the temptation to answer directly. Ask this one first: "Where is the target, in what state of mind, and what does the brand want it to feel or do after seeing the message?"
The answer to that question will point to the platform. Not the other way round.